Exploring Why the Bills and Chargers Excel at the Tush Push Over the Eagles

Buffalo Bills and Los Angeles Chargers Outperforming Eagles' 'Tush Push'

In the world of NFL tactics, the Philadelphia Eagles’ controversial play known as the ‘Tush Push’ has dominated discussions since its rise to fame during their Super Bowl-winning season. However, recent statistics reveal that the Buffalo Bills and Los Angeles Chargers, teams that voted to ban the play, are converting their attempts at a significantly higher rate than the Eagles. While it may seem unexpected, this outcome is a reflection of strategic variances and team dynamics that paint a broader picture of the effectiveness of this contested play.

The Numbers Behind the Controversy

Since the start of the 2025 season, the Eagles have seen a sharp decline in the effectiveness of their ‘Tush Push’, converting a mere 25% of their attempts in the last three weeks, a drastic drop from their prior success rate of 61.5% overall this season. In stark contrast, the Bills have not only rejected the play but so far excelled at it, achieving an 8 for 11 rate with five touchdowns. Meanwhile, the Chargers are at 7 for 8, showcasing their prowess without the aid of this often-criticized strategy.

Why the Shift in Success Rates?

Several factors contribute to this switch in dynamics. For one, the Eagles' offensive line has been grappling with injuries, hampering their ability to execute effectively. The Bills and Chargers, on the other hand, might not utilize the Tush Push to the same extent but have executed their own strategies proficiently, turning what many thought would be a disadvantage into a tactical advantage. In this high-stakes game, execution often trumps ideology.

More Teams Embracing the 'Tush Push'

Despite the recent trend, the Eagles remain the team most associated with the play, having run it more than any other team since its inception into the NFL playbook. While the league average for quarterback sneak success hovers around 81%, the Eagles' reliance could become a double-edged sword as defenses adapt. Teams like the Detroit Lions and Dallas Cowboys have also had impressive conversion rates, hinting at a larger acceptance and refinement of this play across the league. The question for NFL aficionados is whether the Eagles will adapt or if their singular strategy will lead to their downfall.

What Lies Ahead for the 'Tush Push'?

The debate around the 'Tush Push' is far from over. With calls from competitors for its dismantling amid safety concerns, the Eagles need to reassess how they leverage this play while adapting to the evolving style of play in the NFL. Whether facing allies or adversaries of the move, the remedy for the declining success rate might not only lie in execution but also in innovation against a backdrop of strict scrutiny from peers on the field.

As we move forward, the effectiveness of the ‘Tush Push’ will remain a focal point for fans and analysts. Will the Eagles reclaim their top spot in executing this play? Or will the Bills and Chargers continue to lead the charge against the play they sought to ban?